Nov 20th, 2026In a decision issued October 19, 2026*, the Commissioner of Education sustained a parent’s appeal challenging a two-day out-of-school suspension imposed for a single remark made during class. The Commissioner concluded that the district had no record basis to treat the student as a continuing danger, that the suspension was excessive, and that the district should have used the moment to teach rather than to exclude. The district was ordered to expunge the suspension from the student’s record.
The student who is the subject of this appeal was a junior during the 2024-2025 school year. On May 19, 2025, a friend disrupted the student’s Spanish class by pressing his face against the window of the classroom door from the hallway, and making a “creepy face.” The student remarked, “If I ever saw that, I would get a gun.” The teacher overheard the comment, and sent the student to the principal’s office.
In the principal’s office, the student voluntarily submitted to have his backpack and school-issued computer searched. No contraband or inappropriate content was found. He was also interviewed by a school psychologist, who concluded “there was no threat or risk of harm” to the student or others. The student cooperated fully with the investigation. The principal then called the student’s father, and informed him that the student was suspended for two days, effective immediately. Written notice was later handed to the student’s father.
Unless the student poses a danger to themselves or others, when a student is suspended for five days or less, the student’s parent or guardian must be given written notice of the misconduct, the proposed suspension, and their right to request an immediate informal conference with the principal. During an informal conference the student or person in a parental relationship may present the student’s version of events and complaining witnesses may be questioned. The notice must be made within 24 hours of the decision to suspend, and must be made by personal delivery, express mail, or other means. Notice by regular mail does not satisfy the requirements. Whenever possible, notice should also be given orally, but this is not a substitute for written notice.
In reviewing the suspension, the Commissioner found that there was no continuing danger determination that would support an immediate suspension. During the search of his property and school computer, no evidence of weapons, contraband, or other information related to guns or gun violence was found. The risk assessment conducted by the school psychologist concluded that there was no threat or risk of harm. As such, the district could not credibly claim that the student constituted a continuing danger when all evidence suggested the opposite. It was also inappropriate to suspend him without an opportunity for an informal conference beforehand.
The Commissioner also found that the suspension was excessive under the circumstances. A disciplinary sanction must be proportionate to the severity of the offense. The test is whether the penalty is so shocking to the conscience as to warrant substitution of the district’s judgment by the Commissioner. This analysis generally considers the nature of the offense, a student’s age and developmental level, any prior disciplinary history, the extent to which suspension is necessary to ensure the safety of the school community, the extent to which the district has attempted to help the student learn to assume and accept responsibility for their behavior, and other equitable factors.
The Commissioner viewed the student’s comments in context. While finding his remarks about gun violence “inappropriate,” the Commissioner noted that the student’s comment was made in response to his friend disrupting the class, which the student characterized as a “silly prank.” The parties further agreed that his statement was couched as a hypothetical. While relevant, the Commissioner did not feel that a single classmate’s apparent nervousness about the statement** transformed it into a credible threat.
The suspension was ruled to be “inappropriately punitive” by the Commissioner, and was expunged. The Commissioner further stated that this incident should have been used as a teaching moment.
Respondent’s instinct to ensure the safety of the school community was laudable. However, once it became apparent that the student posed no actual threat to himself or others, its decision to impose an out-of-school suspension for an obtuse reference to gun possession was indefensible. Instead, respondent could have, and should have, taken the opportunity to teach the student that it is inappropriate to make jokes about gun violence and other serious matters.... “[P]unitive and exclusionary suspension … will not impart that lesson.”
(Internal citations omitted). Remember, “education lies at the core of any effective disciplinary measure,” and districts should “attempt[] to help … student[s] learn to assume and accept responsibility for their behavior.”
What are the takeaways from this decision?
• Let the evidence drive the assessment of risk of danger. A district that invokes the “continuing danger” exception to skip pre-suspension notice needs a record that supports it. Clean searches and a psychologist’s “no-risk” assessment point the other way.
• Context matters. A statement about violence has to be judged in the circumstances in which it was made, including whether it was hypothetical and what prompted it. A joke does not become a threat simply because it is about guns or violence.
• Secondhand reactions are not enough. A classmate’s nervousness did not make the comment a credible threat, and a teacher’s account that is missing from the written notice and the record carries little weight. More than a single, isolated reaction is needed.
• Proportionality is required. Where a student poses no real safety risk, exclusion from school for what amounts to a poor joke is likely to be viewed as punitive.
• Prefer education to exclusion. Districts are expected to try to help students learn to accept responsibility for their behavior, not just to punish.
• Follow the notice rules. Written notice must be delivered within 24 hours by personal delivery, express mail, or an equivalent means, and a phone call does not substitute.
• Ensure critical evidence is in the record. Make sure the suspension notice and affidavits include any critical evidence that supports the suspension.
• Talk to your Ferrara Fiorenza attorney. We can help you determine whether or not the student poses a threat to the school or himself, what the appropriate disciplinary response is, and ensure that critical allegations are contained in the suspension notice to support the suspension.
*Appeal of C.K., on behalf of her child, from action of the Board of Education of Suffern Central School District regarding student discipline, Decision No. 18,873 (Oct. 19, 2026).
**The classmate is reported to have said, “Did he say what I think he said?” It was only reported in the teacher’s affidavit, and was deemed hearsay.